Koko Lists
Start a new list
Log in
Sign up
← New random battle
Koko Battle
Tap your pick.
Carmelo's Tacos
Carmelo's Tacos was founded in 2018 by Carmelo Gaspar, with Raul Delfin joining as co-owner, starting as a small counter operation inside Hillcrest Market on Capitol Hill rather than a standalone restaurant. That market-stall beginning gave the concept a low-overhead way to prove itself before committing to a full storefront — a common, sensible path for a new taco concept, but one that requires the food to be good enough to draw people specifically to a shared market space. The menu commits to Mexico City-style street food, built around affordable, authentic tacos rather than a fusion or Americanized approach — al pastor, asada, and campechano tacos anchor the lineup, alongside breakfast burritos, quesadillas, and churros. A signature vegan mushroom taco, seasoned with garlic and guajillo chile, has become a specific standout for a menu that could easily have treated a meatless option as an afterthought. That commitment to doing Mexico City street food specifically, rather than a broader Tex-Mex menu, has helped Carmelo's stand out even in a Seattle taco scene that already includes several other Mexico City-style specialists — the campechano and al pastor builds here read as genuinely dialed-in rather than a generic street-taco approximation. By 2021, the concept had grown enough to open its first full-service location on Cherry Street near Seattle University, a 1,300-square-foot space with seating for around 30 people and an outdoor patio — a real step up from the original market counter. A third location later opened on Broadway, extending Carmelo's from a single market stall into a genuine multi-location presence in just a few years. For a Seattle taco list, Carmelo's Tacos is the essential "market stall that earned a real storefront" entry — Mexico City street tacos that built a following one counter order at a time before expanding into full-service locations near Seattle University and on Capitol Hill's Broadway.
VS
Poquitos
Poquitos has operated on Capitol Hill's East Pike Street for more than a decade, describing itself as a vibrant gathering spot built for all ages rather than a narrowly focused taco counter — a bar, a private dining room, and an open-air atrium give it a sit-down restaurant's range even though tacos anchor much of the menu. The kitchen leans into authentic Mexican culinary traditions while sourcing fresh, locally grown Pacific Northwest ingredients, a combination that shows up across dishes like birria tacos, cochinita pibil, and chicken mixiote alongside a chilaquiles-heavy weekend brunch program. A churro sundae closes things out on the dessert end, keeping the menu feeling complete rather than taco-focused to the exclusion of everything else. Craft cocktails and margaritas are as central to Poquitos's identity as the food — the kind of restaurant regulars pick specifically for a festive night out with a group rather than a quick, solo taco order, which sets it apart from the more purely functional street-taco spots elsewhere on this list. That inclusive, all-ages, eclectic-energy framing has let Poquitos become a genuine Capitol Hill anchor over its more-than-a-decade run — a restaurant that reflects the neighborhood's own mix of longtime residents, newer arrivals, and a steady late-night crowd, rather than catering to just one specific audience. For a Seattle taco list, Poquitos is the essential "tacos as part of a full night out" entry — a Capitol Hill restaurant and bar where birria tacos and cochinita pibil share the menu with a serious margarita program, built for a group dinner rather than a fast solo meal.
Next battle
Full comparison
About Carmelo's Tacos
About Poquitos
Popular Battles
1984 vs. Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone
1 votes
Friends vs. Curb Your Enthusiasm
1 votes
Ideogram vs. Sora
1 votes
Navy Pier vs. Bishop Museum
1 votes
Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree vs. Skittles
1 votes
George Carlin vs. Oprah Winfrey
1 votes
