Koko Lists
Start a new list
Log in
Sign up
← New random battle
Koko Battle
Tap your pick.
Frothy Monkey (12 South)
Frothy Monkey opened its original location in a small bungalow on 12th Avenue South in 2004, at a time when the 12 South corridor was still years away from becoming one of Nashville's most walkable, most visited retail strips. The café welcomed its first guests as a specialty coffee shop and all-day bakery, and the bungalow setting gave it a homier, more residential feel than a typical downtown coffee counter. In 2011, the business was purchased by a small group of partners who expanded well beyond the original coffee-and-pastry concept, growing Frothy Monkey into a full all-day restaurant serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner alongside its coffee program, plus craft cocktails, local beer, and wine. That evolution let Frothy Monkey become a genuine all-hours destination on 12 South rather than a morning-only coffee stop, and the concept has since expanded to additional Nashville locations along with outposts in Franklin and Chattanooga. The 12 South original has kept its charming indoor seating even as it added outdoor space and a beer garden to keep up with the neighborhood's growth, and it's become one of the strip's most reliable people-watching spots — a no-reservations café built for lingering rather than a quick in-and-out coffee run. That combination of specialty coffee roots and a full-service, all-day restaurant model is part of what's kept Frothy Monkey busy at nearly every hour it's open, a different proposition than a shop built purely around espresso and pour-overs — coffee is still central to the identity, but it now shares the stage with a genuine kitchen. For a Nashville coffee list, Frothy Monkey is the essential "coffee shop that grew into an all-day café" entry — a 2004 bungalow original on 12 South that expanded into a full restaurant and bar without ever losing its identity as a specialty coffee roaster first.
VS
Barista Parlor (East Nashville)
Barista Parlor's flagship East Nashville location opened around 2011 to 2012, founded by Andy Mumma, who brought roughly 25 years of specialty coffee experience to a converted auto transmission shop on Gallatin Avenue. The industrial bones of the building were kept largely intact rather than smoothed over, giving the café a distinctive, workshop-like aesthetic that set it apart from the softer, more minimalist coffee shops opening around the same time. Mumma built the concept around blurring the line between art and commerce — vintage motorcycles and a genuine vinyl collection sit alongside the espresso bar, and a large patio has made the Gallatin Avenue location as much a social hangout as a place to get a serious cup of coffee. That combination quickly made Barista Parlor the reference point for Nashville's broader third-wave coffee scene; competitors and admirers alike have described the original East Nashville shop as the template the rest of the city's specialty cafés built on. The coffee program itself takes ethical sourcing and sweetness in roasting seriously, treating the beans with the same intentionality as the space's design — a combination that's helped Barista Parlor sustain more than a decade of consistently high ratings across thousands of reviews, a genuinely hard thing to do once a café becomes as photographed and written-about as this one has. Mumma has since built out other Nashville hospitality ventures beyond Barista Parlor, including a tiki bar, and the Barista Parlor brand itself has expanded to additional locations around the city — but the original Gallatin Avenue shop, transmission-shop bones and all, remains the one most closely tied to the brand's founding identity. For a Nashville coffee list, Barista Parlor is the essential "the shop that built the scene" entry — a converted transmission shop turned third-wave coffee flagship, the East Nashville café most other specialty coffee shops in the city have been measured against for over a decade.
Next battle
Full comparison
About Frothy Monkey (12 South)
About Barista Parlor (East Nashville)
Popular Battles
1984 vs. Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone
1 votes
Friends vs. Curb Your Enthusiasm
1 votes
Ideogram vs. Sora
1 votes
Navy Pier vs. Bishop Museum
1 votes
Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree vs. Skittles
1 votes
George Carlin vs. Oprah Winfrey
1 votes
