Koko Lists
Start a new list
Log in
Sign up
← New random battle
Koko Battle
Tap your pick.
Hodad's
Since 1969, Hodad's has been Ocean Beach's answer to the question of what a San Diego burger should feel like: unpretentious, enormous, and covered in whatever will fit. Byron and Virginia Hardin opened the original location, and after 15 years handed it to their son Mike — known locally as "the Boss Man" — who built it into the neighborhood institution it remains today. For decades it stayed a locals' secret, the kind of place regulars pointed out-of-towners toward without really wanting the secret to get out. That changed in 2007, when Guy Fieri featured Hodad's on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives; the restaurant went from a well-loved dive to a destination almost overnight, and the line out the door has been a fixture ever since. The signature order is the bacon cheeseburger: fresh, never-frozen beef, piled high enough that eating one without losing part of it to the plate is genuinely optional. Beyond the classic, the menu leans into its own mythology — the Guido Burger, a tribute to Fieri built on pastrami and Swiss, and the Blue Jay, loaded with blue cheese and grilled onions. "Frings," a hybrid basket of fries and onion rings, is the standard side, and the milkshakes arrive in their frosty metal mixing cups rather than a glass, a small touch that says a lot about the place's priorities. What sells the experience as much as the food is the room itself. Walls are shingled floor to ceiling in license plates mailed in or hand-delivered from across the country, alongside skateboards and surfboards that make clear which beach town you're in. It's loud, it's crowded most days, and it doesn't pretend to be anything other than a burger stand that got famous — no white tablecloths, no reservations, just a counter, a grill, and a line. The original Ocean Beach location remains the flagship, and the Boss Man's family has kept day-to-day management within the same lineage that's run it since Byron and Virginia handed it off — a rarer thing for a restaurant that's had a viral TV moment and could easily have been bought out and franchised into something blander. Portions run large enough that splitting a burger and a shake with a second person is a genuinely reasonable plan, and that value-for-money reputation is part of what's kept the wait worth it even as the crowd has shifted from purely local to a mix of regulars and visitors working through a bucket list built from the Food Network episode. Reviewers consistently land around 4.5 stars, and the praise tends to repeat the same themes: the burger is bigger than advertised, the fries disappear fast, and the vibe is exactly what people picture when they picture Ocean Beach. It isn't a place to go for a quiet meal — it's a place to go hungry, with napkins on standby, for a burger that had earned four decades of word of mouth before a TV show ever showed up to confirm it.
VS
Rocky's Crown Pub
Rocky's Crown Pub has been serving burgers out of the same corner in San Diego's Crown Point neighborhood since 1977, when Chicago transplant Patricia "Patty" Rockwood — who'd moved to San Diego to be near brothers stationed in the Navy — found an old bar at the corner of Ingraham and La Playa and bought it, financing the purchase with her own stock, savings, and borrowed money. Nearly five decades later, the bar is still known by her nickname, and the burger she built the menu around is still the reason people show up. The menu is deliberately narrow: a cheeseburger made from 80/20 ground beef, topped with yellow American cheese, available in a third-pound or half-pound patty, served on a sesame bun with lettuce, red onion, tomato, pickle, and mayo. That's close to the entire food menu. The only real customization options are grilled onions or a swap to Swiss cheese, and fries are available but cost extra rather than coming standard — a small detail that tells you this is a bar that happens to serve one very good burger, not a burger restaurant that happens to serve beer. That bar-first identity matters to the experience: Rocky's is a cash-friendly, adults-only sports bar as much as it is a burger destination, and the atmosphere leans dive — TVs tuned to whatever game is on, a regulars' crowd, and none of the polish of a gastropub. It's the kind of place San Diego Magazine put on its "Best Restaurants" list in 2013 not for ambition but for consistency: the same simple burger, made the same simple way, for over 40 years. The Crown Point setting itself is part of the draw — a quiet residential corner rather than a commercial strip, which means Rocky's regulars are disproportionately neighborhood locals rather than tourists working down a must-visit list, even as the bar's reputation has spread well beyond San Diego through decades of word of mouth and burger-list rankings. The half-pound option in particular has become something of a local rite of passage, and reviewers consistently note that the quality has stayed remarkably consistent through a recent ownership transition that could easily have changed the recipe or the format. Ownership has stayed close to the original spirit even through a recent transition — longtime employee Nick Vendetti, who met his wife Melissa at the bar in 2009, has been in the process of taking over the pub, keeping it in the hands of people who already understood what regulars come back for. For a "thick patty, no-frills" entry on a San Diego burger list, Rocky's is close to the platonic ideal: hand-formed, cooked simply, and unbothered by five decades of trends happening everywhere else in burger culture.
Next battle
Full comparison
About Hodad's
About Rocky's Crown Pub
Popular Battles
1984 vs. Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone
1 votes
Friends vs. Curb Your Enthusiasm
1 votes
Ideogram vs. Sora
1 votes
Navy Pier vs. Bishop Museum
1 votes
Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree vs. Skittles
1 votes
George Carlin vs. Oprah Winfrey
1 votes
