Maggiano's Little Italy

Appears on

• Top 6 Italian Restaurants in America

  Currently #6 · score 0

Reviews

Log in to leave a review.

Barks

Log in to bark.

Similar places

• Rao's

  Rao's opened in 1896 in East Harlem, founded by Charles Rao, and the tiny restaurant — with just a handful of tables — has been run by the same extended family for well over a century, becoming one of the most difficult reservations to obtain of any restaurant in the entire country. The restaurant doesn't take reservations from the general public at all; instead, its limited tables are effectively "owned" by longtime regulars on specific recurring nights, a genuinely unusual system that's made a table at Rao's more a matter of inherited social access than something available to book directly, regardless of a prospective diner's wealth or fame. That exclusivity has drawn a steady stream of celebrities, politicians, and mob-adjacent regulars over the decades — the restaurant's founder's grandnephew, Frank Pellegrino, became a minor celebrity in his own right playing an FBI agent on "The Sopranos" while continuing to run the family restaurant — and Rao's jarred pasta sauce, now sold nationally in supermarkets, has become one of the most successful restaurant-branded grocery products in the country. Rao's combination of over a century of continuous family ownership, its genuinely inherited-access reservation system, and its wildly successful jarred sauce spinoff has made it one of the most culturally mythologized Italian-American restaurants in the entire country, more famous for who can't get a table than for what's actually served.

  BattleCompare
• Carbone

  Carbone opened in 2013 in Manhattan's Greenwich Village, founded by chefs Mario Carbone, Rich Torrisi, and Jeff Zalaznick, built around a deliberately theatrical recreation of a mid-20th-century red-sauce Italian-American restaurant, complete with tableside preparations and a bow-tied waitstaff evoking a specific nostalgic era of New York dining. The restaurant's spicy rigatoni vodka became one of the most talked-about single pasta dishes in the country, a dish that's spawned countless home-cook recreation attempts and copycat versions at other restaurants, an unusually large cultural footprint for one specific menu item at one specific restaurant. Carbone expanded from its original New York location into a genuine national and international hospitality group, opening locations in cities including Miami, Las Vegas, Los Angeles, Hong Kong, and Riyadh, while maintaining reservations so difficult to obtain that securing a table has become its own minor status symbol among serious New York diners. Carbone's combination of its meticulously recreated mid-century Italian-American aesthetic, its viral spicy rigatoni vodka, and its rapid international expansion has made it one of the most culturally significant and commercially successful Italian restaurant concepts of the past decade.

  BattleCompare
• Delmonico's

  Delmonico's opened in 1837 in Lower Manhattan, founded by Swiss immigrant brothers John and Peter Delmonico, and it's widely credited as the first fine-dining restaurant in the United States, a genuinely foundational claim in American culinary history predating most other restaurants on any "oldest in America" list by decades. The restaurant is credited with introducing several dishes now considered permanent fixtures of American cuisine, including Lobster Newberg, Baked Alaska, and the eggs Benedict, along with popularizing the printed à la carte menu itself at a time when most American restaurants served a fixed, limited daily selection rather than letting diners choose individual dishes. Delmonico's steak, a bone-in ribeye cut named directly for the restaurant, has become its own enduringly popular cut sold at steakhouses nationwide regardless of any connection to the original restaurant, a rare case of a single restaurant's signature dish becoming a permanent, generic part of American butchery vocabulary. Delmonico's combination of its foundational status as America's first fine-dining restaurant and its direct role in inventing multiple dishes now considered permanent American culinary staples has made it one of the most historically significant restaurants of any cuisine anywhere in the country.

  BattleCompare
• Il Mulino

  Il Mulino opened in 1981 in Greenwich Village, founded by Fernando and Gino Masci, brothers from the Abruzzo region of Italy, built around a traditional Southern Italian cooking style delivered with a genuinely old-school, tableside-heavy service format that became closely associated with a certain era of New York fine dining. The restaurant became known for a distinctive, almost aggressive hospitality style — servers bringing out unordered antipasti and extra courses as a gesture of generosity — an approach that built intense loyalty among regulars even as it occasionally surprised first-time diners unprepared for a bill reflecting food they never explicitly requested. Il Mulino expanded from its original tiny Greenwich Village space into a broader restaurant group with locations across multiple American cities, while the original location maintained its reputation as one of the most difficult reservations in the neighborhood for decades running. Il Mulino's combination of its traditional Abruzzese cooking, its distinctively generous and assertive tableside service style, and its multi-decade reputation as a defining New York Italian restaurant has made it one of the most influential Italian dining concepts of its era.

  BattleCompare
• Olive Garden

  Olive Garden opened its first location in 1982 in Orlando, Florida, founded by General Mills as part of the company's restaurant division, built around bringing an accessible, mid-priced version of Italian-American comfort food to a mass national audience rather than pursuing high-end fine dining. The chain's "when you're here, you're family" slogan and its unlimited breadsticks and salad became central to its national identity, and Olive Garden grew into the largest Italian-themed restaurant chain in the United States by both revenue and total number of locations, spun off in 1995 into what's now Darden Restaurants. The chain's "Never Ending Pasta Bowl" promotion, offering unlimited pasta refills for a fixed price during a limited annual window, has become one of the most anticipated recurring promotional events in the entire casual-dining industry, drawing significant media coverage and customer lines each time it returns. Olive Garden's combination of its massive national scale, its recognizable unlimited breadsticks-and-salad format, and its hugely popular recurring pasta promotions has made it the single most commercially significant Italian restaurant brand in the entire country by sheer reach and revenue, regardless of its standing among fine-dining critics.

  BattleCompare

More in Food

• Ruffles

  Ruffles was introduced by Frito-Lay in 1958, building specifically on the earlier innovation of ridged potato chips that had been developed and patented by a smaller regional company, Bernhardt "Bert" Kittel, whose original 1954 patent for "Ruffles" ridge-cut potato chips Frito-Lay's predecessor company eventually acquired. The chip's ridged texture was specifically engineered to hold up better under thicker dips than standard flat potato chips, giving Ruffles a distinct functional advantage for dip-based snacking occasions that became central to the brand's marketing positioning. Ruffles grew into one of the best-selling potato chip brands in the United States under Frito-Lay and later PepsiCo ownership, and the brand has released numerous flavor variations over the decades while maintaining its distinctive ridged shape as its core defining product feature. Ruffles's combination of its acquired ridge-cutting patent innovation and its sustained positioning as the go-to potato chip specifically engineered for dipping has made it one of the most commercially significant potato chip brands in American snack food history.

• Fritos

  Fritos were created by Charles Elmer Doolin in 1932, who purchased a corn chip recipe and production equipment from a Mexican restaurant owner in San Antonio, Texas for $100, initially producing the chips in his mother's kitchen before founding the Frito Company to scale up production. The Frito Company merged with H.W. Lay & Company in 1961 to form Frito-Lay, combining Doolin's corn chip business with Herman Lay's potato chip operation into what became one of the largest snack food companies in the United States before PepsiCo's 1965 acquisition of the combined company. Fritos became particularly associated with Texas and broader Southwestern American food culture, and the chip's distinctive corn flavor and crunch made it a foundational ingredient in dishes like Frito pie, a casserole-style dish combining the chips with chili and cheese that remains a regional comfort food staple. Fritos's combination of its founder's humble $100 recipe purchase and its foundational role in Frito-Lay's formation has made it one of the most historically significant corn snack brands in American food history.

• Cheetos

  Cheetos was created in 1948 by Charles Elmer Doolin, founder of the Frito Company, who developed the cheese-flavored corn snack using leftover equipment from his existing Fritos corn chip production line, extruding corn dough into puffed shapes before coating them in cheese powder. The brand's mascot, Chester Cheetah, introduced in television advertising in 1986, became one of the most recognized animated snack food mascots in American advertising, known for his sunglasses and characteristically mischievous personality across decades of continuous television commercials. Cheetos became part of Frito-Lay following Doolin's Frito Company's 1961 merger with H.W. Lay & Company, and the brand's product line expanded significantly to include both puffed and crunchy variations, along with the notably spicy "Flamin' Hot" line that grew into a significant standalone sub-brand and cultural phenomenon in its own right. Cheetos's combination of its origins repurposing Fritos production equipment and its Flamin' Hot line's outsized cultural significance has made it one of the most commercially and culturally influential snack brands in American food history.

• Pringles

  Pringles was developed by Procter & Gamble and launched in 1968, engineered specifically to solve problems associated with traditional potato chips, including breakage during shipping and inconsistent shapes, by creating a uniformly saddle-shaped chip made from a dehydrated potato-based dough rather than sliced whole potatoes. The chip's distinctive tall cylindrical can, designed to prevent the crushing and breakage common with bag-packaged chips, became one of the brand's most recognizable and legally significant design features, and the container's inventor, Fredric Baur, was so proud of the design that part of his cremated remains were reportedly placed inside a Pringles can at his request. Because Pringles are made from reconstituted potato dough rather than being sliced directly from whole potatoes, the product faced early regulatory and labeling disputes in several countries over whether it could legally be marketed simply as a "potato chip" or required a different classification. Pringles's combination of its engineering-driven uniform-shape design solving shipping and packaging problems and its inventor's famously devoted attachment to the product's iconic can has made it one of the most distinctively engineered snack brands in the food industry.

• Doritos

  Doritos originated at Disneyland in the early 1960s, reportedly developed from surplus tortillas at a restaurant in the park's Frontierland area that were being fried and seasoned rather than thrown away, before Frito-Lay acquired the recipe and launched Doritos nationally in 1966. The brand became particularly associated with bold, unconventional flavor innovation, including Cool Ranch, introduced in 1986, and Nacho Cheese, and Doritos has continued releasing limited-edition and unusual flavor variations as a core part of its ongoing marketing strategy. Doritos became one of the most prominent brands in Super Bowl advertising specifically through its long-running "Crash the Super Bowl" contest, launched in 2006, which invited amateur filmmakers to create their own Doritos commercials for a chance to have them air during the broadcast, a genuinely unusual crowdsourced advertising model for a major national brand. Doritos's combination of its unusual Disneyland tortilla-chip origin story and its pioneering crowdsourced "Crash the Super Bowl" advertising campaign has made it one of the most culturally significant and commercially innovative snack brands in the industry.