Prime Pizza

446 N Fairfax Ave, Los Angeles, CA

Last updated 8/27/2026

Prime Pizza built its reputation around a specific, unglamorous format: large, foldable, New York-style slices and pies sold out of a casual, counter-service setup, a genuine departure from the chef-driven, whole-pie-only pizzerias that dominate much of Los Angeles's more talked-about pizza scene. The Fairfax location has become the brand's flagship as the concept has grown into a genuine regional mini-chain. The dough is proofed for a proper crisp-yet-foldable New York-style crust, and the toppings menu leans toward reliable classics rather than chef-driven novelty — pepperoni, mushroom, a solid plain cheese slice — built for speed and consistency rather than a tasting-menu approach to pizza. Late hours are part of the appeal as much as the pizza itself, catering to a crowd that wants a real slice well after most kitchens in the city have closed. That late-night, by-the-slice format filled a genuine gap in a city where good New York-style pizza, available past a normal dinner hour, was historically harder to find than it should have been given the size and diversity of the local food scene. Expanding to multiple Los Angeles-area neighborhoods while keeping prices and format consistent — real by-the-slice and whole-pie counter service, not a scaled-down sit-down menu — has let Prime Pizza build a loyal following among people who want a fast, reliable New York-style slice rather than a reservation-required pizza experience. No host stand, no wait list — just walk up, fold, and eat.

Own this business? Log in to claim this listing.

Appears on

Top 6 Pizza in Los Angeles
Currently #4 · score 0

Reviews

Barks

Similar places

Pizzeria Mozza
Few new pizza restaurants arrive with as much built-in attention as Pizzeria Mozza did in 2006 — a partnership between chef Nancy Silverton, one of Los Angeles's most respected bakers, and restaurateurs Mario Batali and Joe Bastianich, two of the biggest names in American Italian restaurant hospitality at the time. Highland Avenue, and pizza specifically, was a curious choice for that kind of star power, and the restaurant has spent the better part of two decades justifying it. The crust is the whole argument for Mozza's specific style: a chewy, blistered, notably thin dough with real developed wheat flavor, built to hold up under toppings without turning soggy or collapsing under its own weight. The fennel sausage pizza with panna and scallions has become something close to the restaurant's signature order, though the constantly rotating antipasti and daily specials keep regulars coming back for more than just the pizza. The restaurant has held a place in the Michelin Guide's Los Angeles coverage, recognition for a kitchen that treats pizza with the same technical seriousness Silverton's baking career was already known for before Mozza ever opened. That pedigree — a James Beard Award-winning baker partnering with restaurateurs who'd already built a national Italian-restaurant reputation — is part of why Mozza never had to build a following from scratch the way most independent pizzerias do, but it's the crust itself, refined and consistent for nearly twenty years now, that's kept the restaurant relevant long after the initial buzz of the opening faded. Twenty years on, the wait for a table is still proof the crust was never just coasting on the names attached to it.
Casa Bianca Pizza Pie
Sam Martorana had a real pizza pedigree by the time he relocated to Los Angeles from Chicago in the mid-1950s — his father ran a grocery business, and Sam himself had worked a stint at Tony's Pizza back home. He and his wife Jennie, along with Sam's brother Joe, opened Casa Bianca in January 1955, shortly after arriving with three young children in tow, and built the restaurant's entire identity around scratch-made, family-recipe pizza rather than any single gimmick. The sausage pizza is the dish most closely identified with the restaurant: sweetly spiced homemade sausage studded with roasted garlic, piled generously with mozzarella over a crust that's been described as chewy yet crisp, thin but substantial enough to carry real developed wheat flavor rather than just functioning as a base for toppings. The restaurant has stayed a genuine family operation for seven decades — Sam and Jennie's son Ned and daughter Andrea joined the business as it grew, and even in the restaurant's later years, Jennie remained involved in kitchen supervision while Sam personally oversaw the sausage production that gives the signature pizza its specific flavor. Seventy years in the same Eagle Rock storefront, run continuously by the same family, with the same made-from-scratch sausage recipe Sam brought west from Chicago in the 1950s, is a rare thing for any Los Angeles restaurant to sustain — long lines and a no-frills dining room have stayed part of the experience the entire time, treated as a feature rather than something to modernize away. Sam still oversees the sausage; that isn't nostalgia marketing, it's simply how the kitchen has always run.
Masa of Echo Park
Masa of Echo Park was established in 2004 specifically to bring authentic Chicago deep-dish pizza to Los Angeles — a proper, buttery, tall-edged crust and thick, cheese-and-sauce-heavy build that defines the style back in its home city, made with organic and locally sourced ingredients where possible alongside imported Chicago specialties. In a city with no shortage of thin-crust and Neapolitan-leaning pizzerias, Masa has carved out a specific niche as one of the only places locals point to for a genuine deep-dish fix. The build follows deep-dish convention closely — a thick, pan-baked crust with high, buttery edges, a generous layer of cheese, and chunky tomato sauce spooned over the top rather than underneath, the reverse-layering that separates true deep-dish from a merely thick pizza. It's a substantial, knife-and-fork order rather than a quick handheld slice, and portions are built accordingly. The restaurant has become an Echo Park fixture specifically because it commits fully to the format rather than offering deep-dish as one style among several — a bakery-and-pizzeria combination that treats the Chicago-style pie as its core identity rather than a novelty item on a broader thin-crust menu. That single-minded focus is part of what's kept Masa relevant for Angelenos specifically craving deep-dish rather than just good pizza generally — there's a real difference between a restaurant offering a deep-dish option and one built entirely around getting the style right, and Masa has stayed firmly in the second category through years of operation in the same Echo Park neighborhood. Order a slice here and you'll need a fork — that alone separates it from everything else on this list.
Pizzana
Pizzana opened in Brentwood in 2017, built around Neapolitan-style pizza from chef Daniele Uditi, an Italian-trained pizzaiolo who developed his own dough formula — a longer fermentation process aimed at a lighter, more digestible crust than a traditional Neapolitan pie while still keeping the format's soft, char-blistered center and puffed cornicione edge. Uditi's pizzas lean into seasonal, market-driven toppings rather than a fixed traditional lineup, and the restaurant's burrata and other starters have built as much of a following as the pizzas themselves — a full Italian menu built around, rather than just alongside, the pizza program. That combination of technical dough work and a genuinely considered broader menu set Pizzana apart from more pizza-only Neapolitan spots when it opened. The restaurant's Brentwood opening drew real attention within Los Angeles's food press for bringing a more rigorously technical approach to Neapolitan-style pizza to the Westside specifically, a part of the city that hadn't previously had a destination-level Neapolitan pizzeria of its own. Since opening, Pizzana has expanded to additional Los Angeles-area locations, growth that's let more of the city access Uditi's specific dough technique without diluting the standard set at the original Brentwood restaurant. Most pizzerias mention their dough in passing; Uditi built an entire restaurant group around getting that one variable exactly right.
Jon & Vinny's
By 2015, chefs Jon Shook and Vinny Dotolo already had a strong Los Angeles reputation to trade on, built through their earlier restaurant Animal — so when they opened a second, more casual concept on Fairfax Avenue that same year, expectations were already high. Jon & Vinny's answered with a red-sauce Italian-American menu built around pizza, pasta, and an all-day format that runs from breakfast straight through dinner. The pizza program sits on a thin, well-charred crust, with the Popeye — a white pie loaded with spinach, garlic, and a fried egg cracked on top — becoming one of the restaurant's most-ordered and most-photographed items. The broader menu's willingness to serve pizza alongside a full breakfast menu and hearty pasta dishes reflects Shook and Dotolo's larger approach: comfort-forward Italian-American food executed with real chef-level technique rather than a straightforward red-sauce nostalgia act. The restaurant quickly became one of the Fairfax corridor's most reliably busy spots, drawing both destination diners chasing Shook and Dotolo's reputation from Animal and neighborhood regulars treating it as a straightforward daily option — a dual identity that's not easy for a single restaurant to hold. Since the Fairfax original, Jon & Vinny's has expanded to additional Los Angeles locations, extending the same all-day, pizza-and-pasta format to more of the city while keeping the chef-driven technique that distinguished it from typical casual Italian-American restaurants when it first opened. Order the Popeye at 10am for breakfast or 10pm for dinner — the kitchen treats neither request as unusual.