- 1Russ & Daughters
Russ & Daughters has operated on Manhattan's Lower East Side since 1914, founded by Polish-Jewish immigrant Joel Russ, and it remains one of the oldest continuously running "appetizing" shops in the country, a specifically Jewish-American food category built around smoked fish, bagels, and cream cheese rather than hot deli meats. Its name, unusual for the era in explicitly crediting Russ's three daughters who worked in and eventually took over the business, reflected a genuinely progressive family structure for a early-20th-century immigrant-owned shop, and the business has remained family-run across four generations since. Its bagels, served with a rotating selection of the shop's celebrated house-smoked and cured fish, including its renowned Nova Scotia salmon and sable, have made the classic bagel-and-lox combination one of the most historically significant and consistently imitated Jewish-American food traditions in the country. For a New York bagels list, Russ & Daughters is the essential "the appetizing shop that defined it" entry — a four-generation, 1914-founded Lower East Side institution whose bagel-and-smoked-fish tradition remains the historical benchmark for the entire category.
$$casual0 up · 0 down
0 - 2Ess-a-Bagel
Ess-a-Bagel has operated in Manhattan since 1976, building a reputation around exceptionally large, dense, hand-rolled bagels boiled and baked using traditional technique, becoming one of the most frequently cited "best bagel in New York" answers across decades of local food debate. Its bagels' notably substantial size and chewy, dense interior reflect an old-school New York bagel style that many longtime New Yorkers specifically associate with the city's classic bagel tradition, as opposed to the smaller, softer versions more common outside the city. The shop's extensive spread of cream cheese flavors and classic deli-style toppings, combined with its consistently long lines even decades after opening, have made it a genuine destination stop for both longtime residents and visitors specifically seeking a traditional New York bagel experience. For a New York bagels list, Ess-a-Bagel is the essential "the classic New York size and chew" entry — a nearly five-decades-running Manhattan institution whose large, dense, traditionally made bagels remain a frequent answer to the city's eternal best-bagel debate.
$casual0 up · 0 down
0 - 3Absolute Bagels
Absolute Bagels, operating on the Upper West Side near Columbia University since the 1990s, built a devoted following through a Thai-immigrant-owned bagel shop bringing genuinely serious technique to a food category with no obvious connection to its owners' own culinary background. Its bagels, boiled and baked fresh throughout the day using traditional methods, have earned consistent praise for their fresh-out-of-the-oven quality and wide range of flavors, appealing especially to the college-student population near Columbia's campus seeking a reliable, affordable bagel spot. The shop's cash-only, no-frills format and its consistently long lines, especially on weekend mornings, reflect its status as a genuine neighborhood institution built almost entirely on food quality and word of mouth rather than any broader marketing or brand expansion. For a New York bagels list, Absolute Bagels is the essential "unexpected excellence" entry — a Thai-owned Upper West Side shop that's earned a devoted following for genuinely excellent, fresh-baked bagels near Columbia's campus.
$dive0 up · 0 down
0 - 4H&H Bagels
H&H Bagels, founded in 1972 on the Upper West Side, became one of the most nationally famous names in New York bagels during the late 20th century, at one point reportedly the largest bagel producer in the city and a fixture referenced repeatedly in television and film depictions of New York. The original H&H closed in 2011 amid financial and legal troubles, but the brand was revived under new ownership beginning in 2014, reopening with the same traditional boiled-and-baked technique and continuing to trade on the name's decades of accumulated New York bagel cultural cachet. Its continued operation today, including retail and wholesale bagel production, reflects both the brand's genuine historical significance to New York bagel culture and the specific, ongoing effort by its current ownership to preserve and rebuild that legacy after its earlier closure. For a New York bagels list, H&H is the essential "the most famous name, revived" entry — a once-dominant 1972-founded bagel brand that closed and was brought back, carrying decades of New York bagel cultural history along with it.
$casual0 up · 0 down
0 - 5Tompkins Square Bagels
Tompkins Square Bagels opened in the East Village in 2012, building a devoted modern following through a combination of traditional boiled-and-baked bagel technique and an unusually extensive, creatively flavored menu of specialty cream cheeses and sandwich combinations. Its willingness to experiment with a much wider range of cream cheese flavors and specialty sandwich builds than most traditional bagel shops offer gave it a distinctly more contemporary identity, appealing to a younger East Village clientele alongside longtime traditional bagel loyalists. The shop's rapid rise to prominence within just a few years of opening, becoming a regularly cited "best of New York" bagel destination despite its relatively recent founding compared to the city's many decades-old bagel institutions, reflected genuine quality recognition rather than simple nostalgia. For a New York bagels list, Tompkins Square Bagels is the essential "the modern favorite" entry — a relatively young East Village shop that's earned its way into the city's best-bagel conversation through traditional technique paired with genuinely creative flavor combinations.
$casual0 up · 0 down
0 - 6Murray's Bagels
Murray's Bagels has operated in Greenwich Village since 1996, building a reputation around a firmly traditionalist approach that includes a notable, long-standing refusal to toast its bagels, a policy the shop maintains on the grounds that a properly fresh bagel should never need toasting in the first place. That specific stance became something of a local point of debate and even minor controversy among customers accustomed to ordering their bagels toasted elsewhere, and Murray's has held to the policy for decades as a matter of genuine culinary principle rather than simple stubbornness. The shop's dense, chewy, traditionally boiled bagels and its extensive selection of smoked fish and spreads have made it one of Greenwich Village's most consistently recommended bagel destinations, its no-toasting policy ultimately becoming as much a point of pride as a point of contention. For a New York bagels list, Murray's is the essential "we don't toast, and we mean it" entry — a Greenwich Village institution whose famously firm no-toasting policy reflects a genuine, decades-held conviction about what a properly made bagel should be.
$casual0 up · 0 down
0
Suggest an addition
Log in to add a place to this list.
Barks
Log in to bark.