No votes yet — be the first to vote and help rank this list.
- 1Katz's Delicatessen
Katz's Delicatessen has been serving hand-carved pastrami sandwiches from the same corner of Manhattan's Lower East Side since 1888, making it one of the oldest continuously operating delicatessens in the United States and a direct link to New York's Jewish immigrant food culture. Its pastrami sandwich, still hand-cut to order by countermen slicing from whole steamed briskets rather than pre-sliced deli meat, has become the reference standard against which nearly every other pastrami sandwich in the country is measured, piled high enough that eating one with both hands is genuinely difficult. The deli became internationally famous beyond the food world after serving as the setting for the fake-orgasm scene in "When Harry Met Sally..." (1989), with a sign still marking the exact table where the scene was filmed, giving it a rare crossover between culinary and cinematic landmark status. Katz's combination of its century-plus unbroken operating history and its defining role in American pastrami sandwich culture has made it one of the most iconic single sandwiches in the country's culinary history.
Be the first to vote
0 - 2Primanti Bros
Primanti Bros began in 1933 as a cart serving truckers in Pittsburgh's Strip District wholesale produce market, and its signature sandwich — piling french fries and coleslaw directly inside the sandwich alongside the meat — became one of the most distinctive regional sandwich inventions in the country. The sandwich's origin is widely tied to Pittsburgh's working-class trucking and rail-yard culture, with the fries-and-slaw-inside format reportedly designed so laborers could eat a complete meal one-handed without needing a plate or side dishes during short breaks. The original Strip District location remained open essentially around the clock for decades to serve overnight shift workers, and the chain has since expanded regionally while keeping the same distinctive sandwich format that made it a defining piece of Pittsburgh food identity. Primanti Bros's combination of its working-class Strip District origin story and its genuinely unique fries-inside sandwich format has made it one of the most regionally iconic sandwiches in the country.
Be the first to vote
0 - 3Pat's King of Steaks
Pat's King of Steaks, founded by Pat Olivieri in 1930 on the same South Philadelphia corner it still occupies, is widely credited with inventing the Philly cheesesteak after Olivieri reportedly grilled some chopped beef on a hot dog roll for his own lunch and a passing cab driver asked for one too. The stand's rivalry with Geno's Steaks, which opened directly across the street decades later, became a genuine only-in-Philadelphia landmark feud, with the two competing stands' neon signs facing off across the intersection and each maintaining fiercely loyal separate followings. Pat's ordering system, requiring customers to specify "wit" or "witout" (onions) quickly and clearly at the counter, became its own piece of local food culture lore, with a reputation for good-naturedly gruff service toward customers who order incorrectly or hesitate. Pat's combination of its direct claim to inventing the cheesesteak and its enduring cross-street rivalry with Geno's has made it one of the most historically significant single sandwich stands in American food culture.
Be the first to vote
0 - 4Ike's Love & Sandwiches
Ike's Love & Sandwiches was founded by Ike Shehadeh in San Francisco in 2007 and grew into a large West Coast chain built around an enormous, mix-and-match menu of named sandwich combinations, each finished with the chain's signature "Ike's sauce" spread generously inside. The chain's naming convention, giving each sandwich combination a distinct, often punny name (many named after real customers, local sports figures, or pop culture references), created a genuinely enormous menu that regular customers could spend years working through without repeating an order. Shehadeh's early struggles, including working through the sandwich shop concept after other business ventures failed, became part of the chain's origin story as it expanded from a single San Francisco storefront into hundreds of locations across multiple states. Ike's combination of its distinctively enormous named-sandwich menu and its rapid expansion from a single Bay Area shop has made it one of the most recognizable modern American sandwich chains.
Be the first to vote
0 - 5Jimmy John's
Jimmy John's was founded by Jimmy John Liautaud in 1983 near the University of Illinois after his father reportedly offered him either a car or $25,000 to start a business, and the chain grew into one of the largest sandwich franchises in the country built around a deliberately narrow, freaky-fast-delivery-focused menu. The chain's marketing built its entire identity around delivery speed, with "Freaky Fast" becoming its signature slogan and franchise locations competing on internally tracked delivery-time benchmarks, a genuinely different positioning strategy than most competing sandwich chains' focus on menu variety. Jimmy John's deliberately minimal ingredient list per sandwich, favoring a small number of well-executed combinations over an expansive customizable menu, represented a distinct philosophy from chains built around endless customization options. Jimmy John's combination of its speed-obsessed brand identity and its deliberately focused menu has made it one of the most recognizable fast-casual sandwich chains in the country.
Be the first to vote
0 - 6Publix Pub Sub
The Publix Sub, universally known across Florida and the broader Southeast as the "Pub Sub," is a made-to-order deli sandwich sold at the supermarket chain Publix's deli counters, and it has developed a genuinely unusual cult following for a sandwich sold inside a grocery store rather than a dedicated sandwich shop. The sandwich's specific preparation — meat and cheese warmed together before the vegetables and dressing are added — combined with Publix's consistent quality control across its hundreds of Southeastern locations, gave it a reputation for reliability that regular customers came to associate specifically with hurricane-prep grocery runs and everyday lunch routines alike. The Pub Sub became enough of a regional cultural touchstone that it developed an association with hurricane season specifically, since stocking up on Pub Subs before a storm became a widely shared, half-joking Florida tradition documented extensively on social media during major storm events. The Pub Sub's combination of its unusual origin inside a supermarket deli counter and its genuine cultural status as a Florida and Southeast regional icon has made it one of the most distinctive sandwiches in the country.
Be the first to vote
0
Related Lists
Suggest an addition
Log in to add a place to this list.
Barks
Log in to bark.